Raw vs Commercial Food
William Pollak, DVM
“Survival is insured by commercial food; nothing more; not health, not the robustness for life.”
What Are the Benefits of Feeding Raw?
One of my ‘glowing-halo moments’ is seeing yet another ‘raw food’ convert come through door, and extol the virtues of what this raw food has done for “dear little poochie-pie”. Below are some of the ‘cures’ that the raw food diet has wrought:
• Boosted immune system – stronger disease resistance
• No more ‘doggy’ odour – dogs smell fresh, clean
• Healthy skin & shiny coat
• Clean teeth & healthy gums
• Fresh breath – no longer smells like swamp gas
• Behaviour problems lessen – Hyper dogs tend to settle down
• Improved digestion – no more ‘irritable bowels’/diarrhoea
• Less stool & Much less stinky!
• Fewer or no fleas & Less scratching/itching
• All-round increased energy & vitality
• Old dogs get ‘younger’ – arthritis lessens
• Fewer (if any) infertility/breeding problems
• Dogs (and cats) look forward to their meals!
THE RAW FOOD DIET THE COMMERCIAL
DIET TESTS DONE
Tested over the centuries by wild dogs that have continued to thrive in the wild by feasting on their prey (stomach, organs, intestines, muscle meat, bones, and stomach contents consisting of predigested root vegetables, grasses, fruits and berries).
Not tested by any long term feeding trials. Commercial “kibble” and canned pet foods were “discovered” in the 1950′s. Companies like Heinz, Nestles et al created a “niche” for their left-over “not fit for human consumption” foods which can include: moldy grains, rancid restaurant grease (dogs like the smell!), diseased animal tissue, and “animal meal” which can include ground feathers, claws, blood, and fecal matter! The results? We are seeing the rise in allergies, pancreatic and thyroid problems, dysplasia, and other degenerative diseases. (check out the Animal Protection Institute at: www.api4animals.org)
Contains no – or little – grains. Grains are not a part of a dog’s natural diet – in fact, dogs have difficulty in digesting grains.
Usually very high in grain content. Why? Grains are inexpensive (compared to meat). However, a high grain diet can cause insulin swings and overwork the pancreas.
Dogs have NO digestive enzymes in their mouths.
RAW VS COOKED BONES:
Raw bones are nature’s storehouse for minerals, in perfect balance.
Raw bones act as a natural toothbrush – to clean teeth, exercise gums. No need to clean your dog’s teeth, or anaesthetize, as the vet would have to do.
Chewing raw bones help to develop puppy’s jaw and neck muscles.
Cooking destroys and/or alters many of the bone’s nutrients and changes essential fatty acids into “trans-fatty acids” – suspected carcinogens.
Cooked bones sit like concrete in a dog’s stomach, whereas raw bones break down.
Cooked bones can splinter due to the breakdown of collagen.
MEAT and VEGGIES: RAW VS COOKED
Raw food contains “enzymes” – necessary aids to digestion. It also contains amino acids – the building blocks of proteins.
Cooking kills the enzymes needed for proper digestion and stomach health. The body must work hard to replace them. Processing destroys the fragile amino acids.
CANINE and FELINE PHYSIOLOGY
Wolves and dogs have identical gastro-intestinal systems.
Their natural stomach juices are acidic, able to “kill” bacteria like salmonella, etc.
Dogs have “ripping, tearing and shearing” teeth. (No grinders, like humans have)
Cats are true carnivores and cannot live in health without meat. (Francis J. Pottenger’s 10 year study on raw vs cooked foods for cats)
Cooked, grain-based pet foods are not natural to dogs and cats. They create an “alkaline” stomach environment – with lowered defenses against bacteria, etc.
French chemist, Paul Kouchakoff discovered that when cooked/processed food is tasted, white blood cells rush to the intestines. The phenomenon, called “digestive leucocytosis” disrupts the immune system: the body regards the cooked food as a pathogen and works hard to destroy it.
WHAT THE VETS SAY
There is move toward a return to a more natural diet for our companion animals, and there are a growing number of veterinarians in the Greater Vancouver area who now support and see the benefits of the raw food diet.
Vet schools receive their major funding – and “nutritional’ training” – from the multi-national pet food companies.
Fresh, raw foods are not a part of the traditional veterinary culture.
Kibble is “convenient” (for the owner only.)
CONTROL OVER WHAT YOUR DOG/CAT EATS
Feeding raw, you have control over the quality, content and quantity of your pet’s diet – it doesn’t come dehydrated, pre-mixed’, or tinned.
“Variety” – important for both human and animal health – not the same bag of food day-in and day-out.
With commercial pet foods you are never sure of the “quality” of the original ingredients. (Remember that shoe leather is “protein”!)
Many manufacturers use toxic additives that have been added to the food before they get it – and therefore don’t have to note it on their label!
ESSENTIAL FATTY ACIDS
Raw foods contain essential fatty acids necessary for a healthy coat and skin.
Heat and light can destroy EFA’s, yielding harmful trans-fatty acids. Pet food companies often use rancid, restaurant grease to spray on the kibble – dogs are “attracted” to the “smell”!
RAW VS COOKED and PROCESSED
A varied, species-appropriate raw food diet provides an abundance of all the nutrients dogs and cats need to live a healthy life.
Cats and dogs eat their prey raw – as nature intended.
Cooking/heating damages and alters food.
Damaged fats directly suppress the immune system.
Commercial pet food companies have yet to find ovens, dehydrators, or rendering plants in a wild cat or dog’s den!
A raw food diet does not need any chemicals, preservatives, or additives.
Some pet food companies use known cancer-causing preservatives like BHT, BHA, and Ethoxyquin in their food. Some add “food enhancers” that make food “taste better” – often “addicting” animals to one brand of food.
Animal sources (easily digested and assimilated by dogs and cats)
High grain sources (not easily digested)
Variety in the diet helps to avert allergies, and insure a well-rounded diet. With a raw food diet, this is possible.
There is no variety. Your pet eats the same thing, day after day. (How well would we fare if fed only “fast foods” for all of our life?)